The entire incoming class of American University was asked to read this book, 'The Moral Underground: How Ordinary Americans Subvert An Unfair Economy' by Lisa Dodson, in order to be prepared to discuss it in their freshman English classes. Since I somehow escaped the 100 level English classes, I found (after purchasing it, of course) that I did not in fact have to read it. The back cover reminded me vaguely of Freakonomics meets sociology though, so I thought what the hey, I like to read, let's give it a shot.
I didn't really know what I was getting into.
I'll be honest, it's not the most entertaining read. One thing I adored about Steven Levitt's method of explaining Freakonomics was the humor and easy-to-read-even-though-it's-math factors he included in his writing. What Dodson lacks in confusing mathematical information though, she more than counters with her very deliberate, very factual, and therefore slowly processed accounts and interviews. (I find it's a novel best chipped away at in doses, rather than swallowed whole, but also ponder whether that was in fact her purpose in using that particular style...)
The real reason this isn't an easy read, however, has less to do with her style and more to do with her information. I'll admit it; I haven't finished it yet. However, I can tell you that the entirety of part one analyzed the American workplace in entry level jobs, and I can tell you that the information thoroughly bothered me (although perhaps not in the way Dodson intended). Her exposition of each interview gives each section the feeling of a call to action, but I can't trust the rather one sided report she gives. At this point, I'm sure countless readers would object and tell me that 'the managers we hear from run the gamut, from those who think entry level workers with families are uncommitted and irresponsible workers to those who pad their employees hours so they can afford food!' And with that statement I would agree. But what about the workers she speaks to? Every book has an agenda and what I don't trust about Dodson is that she attempts to cover hers up with a wide range of employers... but only one type of employee.
The picture she paints is of workers, largely women, and largely single mothers, who try their hardest but just can't get by in an economy that ignores them. People who work more than one job to pay the bills and are forced to put their children in neglectful situations because there really is nothing else they can do, having explored every loophole they can and made every responsible decision for the sake of their children. But this one sided perspective neglects the raging population that really just doesn't have that sense of responsibility, or perhaps any sense at all! There has to be a line between what is the systems fault and what is personal responsibility. I have to wonder, between all the heart-wrenching tales of being screwed by American business policies, how many unemployed single mothers she met who- despite being unmarried, fiscally unstable, and emotionally stressed, depressed or otherwise unstable- continued to bring children into that unhealthy and unforgiving environment?
My mother and I were discussing a family friend today, an old student of my mothers who she grew close to and who used to babysit for my family. She has never been married, or even in a stable, non-abusive relationship. She has been unemployed for a large portion of the last 3-4 years, is physically unable to perform some work after an injury incurred at her old workplace (construction, I believe?), which she could not afford to get help for due to a lack of health insurance. She has family that is unsupportive at best and has paid money she doesn't have to lawyers and court fees.
She has also just had a fourth child.
The first two are currently in state custody.
There must be a line. There must be a point at which people decide, I am incapable of caring for more people than this. I should wait until I am financially and emotionally able to support the children I have before I have more.
Please don't misunderstand; I'm not for denying people the joy of becoming parents. I'm not endorsing abortion for parents-to-be who feel unable to support their children.
But I am supporting a critical view of whether or not it would be good for THE CHILD.
The second part of Dodson's book is about the children of workers living above the poverty line but below the national average. It should be interesting.
I'm not saying parents are entirely to blame for the crisis encroaching upon lower-middle class families. But I'm also not sure I'm willing to go along with Dodson in blaming the system. Perhaps I'm being cynical, but there must be a point at which The Man is a reason, not an excuse.

No comments:
Post a Comment